TheKeepersNetflix

I recently watched the Netflix series, The Keepers. For those, who, like myself, didn't know the subject matter, it is the investigative story of sexual abuse allegedly perpetrated by a Catholic priest at an all-girl Catholic high school in Baltimore during the period of 1967-1975, and his possible connection to the still unsolved murder of one of the nuns who taught there.

The story is sobering, but what caught my attention most was the position of the diocese during it all. It is the story of ecclesiastical supervision failure. It is sobering to me because that is a part of the work which is given to district presidents, too. When pedophilia came to light in the Catholic Church some years ago, I was told there was a website which documented pedophilia cases in every Christian denomination. I clicked on the LCMS page and held my breath. Thankfully, there were not many, but even so, one is too many. Of course, when supervisors discover these, the fear on their part is the damage such "news" could create to the Church, the loss of confidence in (and enrollees at) their schools, and the overall embarrassment to the Christian faith. Nevertheless, as the Netflix series shows, those fears are nothing when compared to the damage which silence and denial caused. Had leadership responded after the first accusation, the lives of at least 40 women would have turned out differently.

I do appreciate a reasonable quandary in which we ecclesiastical supervisors find ourselves. What to do when only one incident exists? What to do when it is only a "he said/she said" matter with no corroboration? It is easy to look back on a situation and Monday morning quarterback. I believe we do well to have trained investigators at our disposal, for clergy are not normally trained for such inquiries. It would seem that the diocese involved acted dangerously after they had received the first report of pedophilia and then transferred the priest to teach at a nearby parochial high school!

If the allegation proves to be false, a professional's reputation and career is shot. If it proves to be true, a child's life is seriously damaged. No one wins in such situations. No monetary damage awarded can compensate in either case. But at least the Christian Church seems to have learned one lesson – covering up or glossing over such allegations is not the answer. We take these things seriously and are committed to following where the evidence leads. No matter the rationale, the source of all dishonesty and cover-up is, of course, the Father of Lies. Speaking less than the truth can never be the best policy in these matters.